I went back through the thread and tried to interpret what people meant. This is how I interpreted things (and I know from playing that I don't always interpret things correctly so move your name if it is in the wrong category)
1. kaner406 - prefer non-anon, will play anon
2. mfarb
3. YouCan'tHandleTheTruth - prefer non-anon but will play either
4. Darkarus
5. Alpha@Omega
6. Utom
7. Halt
8. bluecthulhu - prefer anonymous
9. Hirnsaege - prefer anon
10. rexgarum - prefer anon
11. krellin - either (prefer non)
12. didigoose - prefer anon
13. DEFIANT
14. Leif_Syverson - prefer non-anon, will play either way.
15. Dr. Recommended -anon
16. Geronimo
17. Trubbis - either, prefer non-anon
18. RUFFHAUS 8 - either (prefer non-anon)
19. GOD
20. bozo - prefer anon
21. DoubleCapitals - anon, but doesn't really care
22. CubanJedi
23. Mapu - anon
24. y2kjbk
25. Skylin- non-anon, but would play anon
26. Sendric - either
27. Drano019 - prefer non-anon
28. rysk - prefer non-anon
29. LoveDove -either
30. Fischfix
31. KICEMEN17 - anon or non-anon
32.
33.
34.
35.
Only play anon: 2 (Mapu, Dr. Recommended)
Only play non: 0
Prefer non: 9 (kaner, YCHTH, krellin, Leif, Tribbis, RUFFHAUS, Skylin, drano, rysk)
Prefer anon: 6 (bluechtulu, Hirnsaege, Rex, didigoose, bozo, DC)
Doesn't care: 3 (Sendric, LoveDove, KICEMEN17)
abstained: 11 (mfarb, Darkarus, Alpha@, Utom, Halt, DEFIANT, Geronimo, GOD, CubanJedi, y2kjbk, Fischfix)