It's me :)
I do understand your point, as my experience on playdiplomacy was abysmal. I also think that the standards that webDip tries to adhere to are a major contributing factor to its overall quality. Ultimately, I'm glad that I don't have to make decisions like the one being discussed. It seems highly likely that if cases are considered for reinstatement there will be some inherent arbitrariness and unfairness to some that get denied. In your case, I certainly don't know enough to have an opinion, though it's clear that you are persistent and have been consistently trying to earn another chance, and you have some support from webDip members who continue to plead your case.
I was joking, obviously, about my multi-accounts, but 3-2 is an accurate read on my view of the situation. I think there are fair points on both sides of the issue. I'm glad that the community and admin care enough about the quality of the site and the wishes of membership to hold such discussions, rather than be completely rigid. Whatever the outcome, it won't change my enjoyment of the site and if Agent K - or yourself - is reinstated, it's a blank slate as far as I'm concerned. I will let my own direct experience inform my opinions from there.
Diplomacy Etiquette
, who have played that variant multiple times joining? Not going to name any names, but it happened recently and I don't understand it. Do these people just say "Well, this look like an easy way for me to get more points." Is there anything that can be done to stop it from happening? Maybe if there was a script that can tell if you've played that variant more than once in the past?
)
)
)
