Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
Page 101 of 160
FirstPreviousNextLast
KingCyrus (1258 D)
06 Apr 14 UTC
WWII needs YOU!
gameID=18949

Come on people, join now!
0 replies
Open
Spartan22 (1883 D (B))
17 Mar 14 UTC
(+1)
Vdip March Madness?
March Madness (college basketball for those that don't know) is finally rolling around. I was curious if anyone here would want to do a bracket challenge.
93 replies
Open
Battalion (2386 D)
30 Mar 14 UTC
Grey Press - variantID=50
Anyone up for giving this a go? It's like the normal classic, with the ability to send anonymous messages in addition to normal ones. I was thinking it would be 1 day phase, Anon, and full press. I'm not bothered about buy-in.
Battalion (2386 D)
31 Mar 14 UTC
No one? I thought that you guys were cool.
GOD (1791 D Mod (B))
31 Mar 14 UTC
In school I am often referred to as KOOL MC, but I played the variant once and did not like it, sorry :P
Battalion (2386 D)
31 Mar 14 UTC
Fair enough. Why didn't you enjoy it?
GOD (1791 D Mod (B))
31 Mar 14 UTC
because i could find no way to really use the grey press feature...
Spartan22 (1883 D (B))
31 Mar 14 UTC
I played once and the only way it's really useful that I found was in global to try and influence global ideas one way or the other. Basically analyzing each turn "objectively" trying to put ideas in players heads. I don't see a way it can be effective in private press.
Hirnsaege (1903 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
i think greypress ist better than public-chat-only with names.
yet it's not my favourite ...
Battalion (2386 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
I was thinking about using it to give a yearly 'European News' report as a bit of extra fun (which obviously doesn't really work as well if everyone knows who is giving it!).

Otherwise I suppose it can be played as a normal classic. Would anyone be up for that?
bozo (2302 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
(+1)
This variant could be interesting in a public press game where only "grey" message were allowed.
Battalion (2386 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
That would be very interesting indeed. Are you up for that, bozo?
Battalion (2386 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
I think that it would still be best Anon, though Hirnsaege.
bozo (2302 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
I do not believe the option for only "grey" messages is supported, I think it would have to be agreed upon by everyone in the game.
Battalion (2386 D)
01 Apr 14 UTC
Yeah, that's fine, it's fairly easy to police.
Battalion (2386 D)
03 Apr 14 UTC
Who's up for that then? Public press, grey press only.
Raro (1449 D)
04 Apr 14 UTC
This is a fun variant IMO. If it were 3 days or more, I could play but that's probably too long for most of you. I don't think I would try enforcing "grey" only press because it would be too easy for people to accidentally not use grey press, and possibly using it for advantage. From what I remember, you have to follow pretty rigid guidelines to get a message to be grey press, I seem to remember people having a difficult time doing it right, however I didn't because I read carefully the rules.
Battalion (2386 D)
04 Apr 14 UTC
The function doesn't seem that difficult to get right (quoted below).

"Anonymous "grey" messages can be sent to a country or global. First click on the "Grey" tab at the top of the dialogue area. To send a grey message to a country just type the country name followed by a colon and your message. This will then be sent to just that country. To send a grey message to everyone just type global followed by a colon and your message. Anything other than this will not go anywhere and result in an error message printed in the chat window.
For PublicPress only games you need to type grey followed by a colon in the global chat to send your message anonymous. "
Battalion (2386 D)
04 Apr 14 UTC
To be honest, I'd be up for whatever most people want to do in both phase length and game type, I just want to give it a go. Am I right in saying that the potentially interested are:
- Battalion
- bozo
- Raro
- Hirnsaege?
kaner406 (2061 D Mod (B))
04 Apr 14 UTC
From memory the gray press variant was implemented after a lengthy forum discussion about the differences between Face to Face dip and Internet dip. One of the things that came up was the ability to 'send' players anonymous messages - eg. in FtF a written note regarding discussions held with other players could be passed to jinx negotiations.

Having said this I don't have time at the moment to join a GP game, but if I did I would definitely be interested in joining.
bozo (2302 D)
04 Apr 14 UTC
I would be interested in a grey press only game, but I am not sure it will work if players are not prevented from sending normal messages.
Raro (1449 D)
04 Apr 14 UTC
I don't think there is a way of enforcing grey press only. You could do global only and tell everyone that it is grey press only, but what do you when someone types in an important message to somebody and says "oops, I forget to type in global: whatever"?
RUFFHAUS 8 (2490 D)
04 Apr 14 UTC
"This variant could be interesting in a public press game where only "grey" message were allowed. "

@Bozo, excellent observation. This kind of variant is extremely fun. A few years back I played in and GM'd a couple of games on the Imperial map that offered *only* public press, with the options for white, grey, and black press. With the right roster of players it can be a roller coaster.

To summarize the concept, all press was public. In the games I played, this meant sending it via email to the GM, who collected and posted it at scheduled intervals. I'm not sure if the game options support this, but it could be handled in a forum by linking the game (created as anonymous) in each post. Therefore you create the game as gunboat - no press, and then handle press through the forum with strict rules that ALL press most be anonymous (which is accomplished by linking the game in your post).

White Press: a message written by a player playing a nation (Austria), representing that nation (Austria).

Grey Press: A message written by a player claiming no identity of nation at all

Black Press: A message written by a player (Austria) posing as another nation (England).

All press is public and anonymous, so it's a war of wits to decipher who is real, and who is Memorex.
bozo (2302 D)
05 Apr 14 UTC
Perhaps the "Classic-GreyPress" variant could be modified to form a new variant, "Classic-GreyPressOnly".


21 replies
gopher27 (1606 D Mod)
28 Mar 14 UTC
Grad Students, Former Grad Students or IT Professionals?
Are you a graduate student, were you a graduate student when you joined this site or are you an IT professional?


Gopher----grad student
15 replies
Open
Rules Question/ Possible Glitch?
gameID=18823
Does anyone have an explanation for why Prussia didn't take Holland from France? RH moved to HOL with support from KIE. It seems that the support was cut, but I don't see any moves to KIE.
Thanks
3 replies
Open
Decima Legio (1987 D)
26 Mar 14 UTC
(+2)
Games history
Before taking a break from the site, I’d like to propose a couple of enhancements for the end-game analyses.
5 replies
Open
RUFFHAUS 8 (2490 D)
25 Mar 14 UTC
Redscape Games III - PBEM Tournament Results
Redscape Games III has come to a conclusion. A summary of the final standings is below:

8 replies
Open
RUFFHAUS 8 (2490 D)
07 Mar 14 UTC
(+1)
Interesting Episode of Diplomacy From WWII
I found this encounter from the Second World War to be extremely interesting, and not at all out of the context of some of the negotiations in our Diplomacy games.
92 replies
Open
ZoMBi3 (1012 D)
26 Mar 14 UTC
live 1v1
0 replies
Open
The Ambassador (2124 D (B))
12 Mar 14 UTC
(+2)
If WW1 was a bar fight
Thought you guys here would appreciate this one. Apologies if you've read it already.

http://m.quickmeme.com/p/3vu14a
25 replies
Open
cypeg (2619 D)
23 Mar 14 UTC
Loading page in Orders section
Hi guys, all my games show "loading page" so I cant issue orders.
3 replies
Open
GOD (1791 D Mod (B))
23 Mar 14 UTC
Dutch Revolt question
This may be a stupid question, but can armies be convoyed to wadden territories?
4 replies
Open
^__^ (1003 D)
12 Mar 14 UTC
live game: classic map
there has never been a live game on the classic map on this site. i'm kind of wanting to start one. would anyone be interesed in joining?
41 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
22 Mar 14 UTC
Spring 01 Gobble replacement
http://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=18645

This game hasn't started yet, but France NMR'd for spring 01 so we need a replacement. Since this is gobble earth, France has territory all over the map. It'd be good to get a replacement and you won't start at any disadvantage.
0 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
11 Mar 14 UTC
Join the next Chaos - Public Press game.
http://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=18632
This type of game is the most chaotic out there, with every turn being a surprise.
3 replies
Open
Wiesl (1079 D)
21 Mar 14 UTC
Westeros
I cant find the Westeros-map, where is it?
1 reply
Open
The Ambassador (2124 D (B))
20 Mar 14 UTC
New take on Modern Diplomacy variant
Anyone notice...
2 replies
Open
KingCyrus (1258 D)
18 Mar 14 UTC
New Variants
How does one make a new variant?
3 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
18 Mar 14 UTC
Premature Draw! Crazy Classic 34P Game
http://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=14633
see below
9 replies
Open
The Ambassador (2124 D (B))
16 Mar 14 UTC
Was VDip down over the weekend?
I tried over and over again and the site was done from multiple devices and browsers. Now it seems I've missed turns in 2 games. Anyone else with the same problem?
13 replies
Open
Lackbeard (966 D)
17 Mar 14 UTC
Quick live
Just looking for a quick 1 v 1 live game :) gameID=18726
0 replies
Open
Science! (880 D)
17 Feb 14 UTC
Question About American Conflict Variant
Are the 'notionally held' SCs essentially normal neutral SCs? For example, if I'm England and I occupy Calgary, do I get a build? Can you build in notionally held SCs?
6 replies
Open
Oli (977 D Mod (P))
05 Dec 13 UTC
On the subject of CYOC and anonymity..
Some input is needed....
16 replies
Open
pyrhos (1268 D)
14 Mar 14 UTC
Map idea
I was sitting home and I thought "it might be possible to make a 1 vs 1 map about mejirestaration"
16 replies
Open
XII (1114 D)
22 Dec 13 UTC
Map Colonial Diplomacy
This map does not use the Trans-Siberian Railway rule. The GM create it want the map more beautiful ?
10 replies
Open
Oli (977 D Mod (P))
11 Mar 14 UTC
New stat CDs / NMRs takeovers.
This thread is for discussion about a new CD / takeover stat.
19 replies
Open
Safari (1530 D)
12 Mar 14 UTC
2 Players Needed for Gunboat Test Game
Hi everyone, I'm setting up a gunboat to test the balance of my map Atlantic Colonies. It's in the stage of testing the final balance, and it's a rather different map, so come play and have fun! It's 1 day 12 hour phases.
http://lab.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=191#gamePanel
(It's on the lab, so just clicking on the game ID won't work--you have to copy the whole URL).
3 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
12 Mar 14 UTC
(+1)
FGA
Anyone interested in taking over Austria on a FGA map? It's currently winning but I lost interest in playing. Please contact- atlas
ID#18302
http://vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=18302
4 replies
Open
Lotte di potere sotto il grande Regno di Mairo
Anyone has the password pls PM me so i can take over
0 replies
Open
Retillion (2304 D (B))
09 Mar 14 UTC
Integrity ?
I have just seen, in the players' profile, the new statistics called "integrity".
30 replies
Open
Page 101 of 160
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top